Vai al contenuto

Edexcel A level Psychology

A-Level · EdexcelPsychology20 appunti in 9 cartelle, 72 KB

20 note di ripasso per Edexcel A-Level Psychology, create da cookie, in 9 sezioni che seguono gli argomenti del corso.

Notes for Pearson Edexcel A level Psychology (9PS0), in folders for the nine topics of the specification in its order, with one folder for each optional topic (criminological, child and health psychology). The statistics and research methods are in the last folder. Delete the option folders you do not take.

Contenuto

La prima nota

Social psychology / Obedience

Milgram's obedience study

Stanley Milgram (1963) wanted to know whether ordinary people would obey an instruction to harm another person. His participants were men recruited from the local area, who were told they were taking part in a study of memory and learning. Each one was assigned the role of "teacher" and was asked to give an electric shock to a "learner" every time the learner gave a wrong answer. The learner was an actor who did not receive real shocks, but the teacher heard him protest and, at higher levels, fall silent.

When a teacher hesitated, the experimenter used a fixed set of prods, such as "The experiment requires that you continue." The shock switches ran from 15 volts to 450 volts. Of the 40 participants, 26 (65 per cent) went all the way to the maximum switch, which was marked as dangerous.

Agency theory

Agency theory explains obedience by a change in the way a person thinks about their own actions. In the autonomous state, people act according to their own wishes and take personal responsibility for what they do. When they see an authority figure, they can move into an agentic state, in which they see themselves as the agent of the authority and feel little personal responsibility for the outcome.

The move from one state to the other is called the agentic shift. Agency theory predicts that it happens most readily when the authority is seen as legitimate. An experimenter in a lab coat, working for a university, has that legitimacy, and this helps to explain why participants kept going.

Social impact theory

Latané (1981) proposed that the effect of other people on an individual depends on three factors: the strength of the source (how powerful or important they are), their immediacy (how close they are in space and time) and their number. Social impact theory is less about a single authority and more about how the presence of others shifts behaviour, so it can explain why obedience and dissent both happen in groups.

Milgram's variations

Milgram ran many variations of his study, and several show that the situation matters a great deal.

  • In Experiment 10, the study was run in a rundown office block rather than at a prestigious university, and obedience was lower than in the original study. The setting, and not only the authority, shaped how far people went.
  • In Experiment 7, the instructions were given by telephone. Obedience fell, because the experimenter's presence and authority were weaker.
  • In Experiment 13, an ordinary man, rather than the experimenter, gave the orders. Obedience also fell, which suggests that the perceived authority of the person giving the orders is central.

Each variation changes the situation while keeping the task the same, so it isolates which situational factors encourage dissent and which encourage obedience.

Individual differences, gender and culture

Obedience is not the same for everyone. Adorno and colleagues (1950) described the authoritarian personality, a set of traits linked to respect for authority, prejudice and rigid thinking, and measured it with the F-scale. Some research therefore links obedience to personality, so that some people are more likely to obey whatever the situation.

Gender and culture also matter. Differences in obedience between men and women, and between cultures, are generally attributed to environmental effects, because people learn the norms of the society they grow up in.

Contemporary research

Burger (2009) replicated Milgram's procedure with 70 participants. For ethical reasons he stopped the procedure at 150 volts, the point at which the learner first asks to be let out. Up to that point, obedience was similar to Milgram's findings, which suggests that the basic pattern has lasted. Because Burger stopped early, his study cannot show whether the full 450-volt result still holds.

Evaluating obedience research

Milgram's work raises questions about ethics. Participants were deceived about the true purpose of the study, and many were distressed, so the findings have to be weighed against the harm done. Obedience research can also be criticised as reductionist, because it reduces a complex social choice to a single task with a shock switch.

The debate between personality and situation is a useful way of judging the evidence. Milgram's variations support the situation, while the authoritarian personality supports the individual. Most psychologists now treat the two as working together.

E altri 19: aprine uno qualsiasi dall’elenco qui sopra.

Valutazioni

Non ci sono ancora recensioni scritte. Aggiungi queste note alle tue e potrai essere il primo a lasciarne una.