跳至內容

AQA A level Law

A-Level · AQALaw20 則筆記,位於 5 個資料夾,78 KB

cookie 製作的 AQA A-Level Law 考試準備筆記,共 20 篇,分為 5 個部分,依照課程主題編排。

Notes for AQA A level Law (7162), in folders for the nature of law and the legal system, criminal law, tort, and the two Paper 3 options: the law of contract and human rights. Each option has its own folder, so delete the one you do not take once the notes are yours. Each topic is split into notes on its sub-topics, with the cases and statutes the content names.

內容

第一則筆記

The nature of law and the legal system / Nature of law, morality, justice and the rule of law

What makes a rule a legal rule

A legal rule is one that the state will enforce through its courts or through sanctions. A rule of etiquette, a religious commandment or a club's bylaws may guide behaviour, but if nobody can take a case to a court and obtain an order or a penalty, the rule is not law in the legal sense. This matters because the legal system can fine a person, imprison them, order them to pay damages or take their property. Those powers need a justification that a social norm does not.

Law is usually divided into criminal and civil law. Criminal law defines conduct that the state treats as a wrong against society as a whole. The prosecution is brought in the name of the Crown, in England and Wales usually by the Crown Prosecution Service, and the aims are punishment, deterrence and protection of the public. Civil law deals with disputes between individuals or organisations. The claimant brings the action, and the usual remedy is compensation, or an order requiring the defendant to act or to stop acting. One event can fall under both. A driver who injures a pedestrian may be prosecuted for a driving offence and also sued in negligence, and the two cases are decided separately, with different standards of proof.

Sources of law

English law has three long-standing sources. Statute law is made by Parliament in Acts, and by the secondary legislation that Acts authorise. Common law is developed by judges in their decisions, and it is binding through the doctrine of precedent. Custom is a long-established practice, local or general, that the courts recognise as binding if it is certain, has been used without interruption and is accepted as obligatory. Customary rules are now rare in practice, but they show that law can grow from what people have always done, not only from what a legislature enacts.

Law and morality

Law and morality overlap, since many criminal offences, such as murder and theft, condemn conduct that almost everyone regards as wrong. The question is whether the law should enforce a moral view simply because it is a moral view.

The Hart-Devlin debate turned on that question. The Wolfenden Report of 1957 recommended that homosexual acts between consenting adults in private should no longer be criminal, and argued that the law should not concern itself with private morality except to preserve public order and decency. Lord Devlin, in The Enforcement of Morals (1959), replied that a society is held together by a shared morality, and that the law may enforce that morality because a society that loses its common morals loses its cohesion. H.L.A. Hart, in Law, Liberty and Morality (1963), argued that the law should be justified by the harm it prevents to others, not by its conformity with a moral view, and that enforcing morality for its own sake interferes with individual liberty.

The debate is harder in a pluralist society, where people hold many different moral views. If there is no single morality the law can reflect, enforcing one view means choosing between them. The harm principle, associated with J.S. Mill, offers a way through: conduct should be criminalised only when it harms others. Critics respond that harm is itself a moral judgement, and that the law also protects values such as dignity, which cannot be reduced to physical harm.

Justice

Justice is the subject of several competing theories. Natural law theory holds that law is grounded in moral principles that exist independently of human enactment, so an unjust law is in a sense not law at all. Legal positivism holds that law is what has been validly enacted, whatever its moral content, so whether a law is just is a separate question from whether it is law. Aristotle distinguished distributive justice, the fair allocation of benefits and burdens, from corrective justice, which puts right a wrong between two parties. John Rawls, in A Theory of Justice (1971), asked people to choose principles of justice behind a veil of ignorance, not knowing their own place in society, and argued that they would choose principles that protect the least advantaged.

Whether the law achieves justice depends on which theory is used. Civil and criminal law can deliver formal equality, treating like cases alike, but people disagree about whether particular outcomes are fair, and about whether the law itself distributes burdens fairly.

The rule of law

The rule of law is the idea that law governs everyone, and that power is exercised only through law, not arbitrarily. A. V. Dicey set out its meaning in English constitutional writing in 1885. He said that no person should be punished except for a clear breach of law established in the ordinary courts, that everyone, including officials, is subject to the ordinary law, and that rights are protected by the decisions of the courts.

A modern account groups the rule of law into three ideas. First, no person should be sanctioned except in accordance with the law. Second, everyone is equal before the law. Third, the law should be fair and clear, so that people can know what is required of them and can be heard before a sanction is imposed.

The rule of law applies in three places. It applies to law making, because the executive must act within the powers Parliament has given it, and courts can check that it has done so. It applies to the legal system, because judges must be independent and courts must be accessible. It applies to substantive law, because criminal and civil rules must be stated clearly enough to be followed. The rule of law concerns the form of law and how power is exercised. It does not by itself say that a particular rule is morally right, which is why the rule of law and justice are separate questions.

還有 19 個:可以從上方清單開啟任何一個。

評分

還沒有文字評論。把這些筆記加到自己的筆記中,就能成為第一個留下評論的人。