コンテンツへ移動

SQA Advanced Higher Modern Studies

Advanced Higher · SQAModern Studies5個のフォルダーに37件のノート、230 KB

試験勉強用ノート37件。cookieが作成。コースのトピックに沿った5個のセクションに分かれています。

Notes for SQA Advanced Higher Modern Studies (X849 77), in folders for research methods and source evaluation, the three question paper sections, and the project-dissertation, with one note per topic. Follows the course specification, version 2.0 (September 2019). Delete any section your class does not take once the notes are yours.

内容

最初のノート

Research methods and source evaluation / Official statistics and reports

What official statistics are

Official statistics are numbers collected or published by government bodies and public agencies, such as the population, employment, crime, health and income. In the United Kingdom the largest producer is the Office for National Statistics (ONS), which runs the census for England and Wales and publishes the labour market figures, the inflation figures and much of the economic data. In Scotland the census is carried out by National Records of Scotland, and the Scottish Government publishes its own statistics on health, education, crime and the economy. The Office for Statistics Regulation checks that these figures meet a published standard, and it can award or withdraw the status of national statistics.

Official statistics are used so often because they are collected in a consistent way over long periods, cover the whole population, and are published for anyone to check. A researcher studying inequality in Scotland, for example, can compare income figures collected by the same survey over twenty years, which a small private survey could not provide.

The census

A census is an attempt to count and describe every household in a country on one day. The UK census is taken every ten years. The most recent one for Scotland was carried out in March 2022, and it asked about the household's size, the age and sex of each member, the ethnic group, religion, languages spoken, health, qualifications and employment. Because it covers everyone, the census is the best source for small areas, such as a single council ward, and for groups that are too small to be picked out reliably by a sample survey, such as people from a minority ethnic group living in one town.

A census is expensive, takes years to plan, and gives a picture only at one moment. Between censuses, the figures are estimated from registrations, such as births, deaths and migration, and these estimates become less accurate the further one moves from the last count.

Administrative data and recorded crime

Much official data is not collected for research at all. It is a by-product of a process, such as the records a benefits office keeps when it pays a claim, the registrations a hospital makes when a patient is admitted, or the crimes the police record when a report is made. These are called administrative data. They are cheap to use and cover everyone who has contact with the system, but they measure the system's activity rather than the thing itself.

Recorded crime is the clearest example. The police statistics count the crimes reported to them and recorded by them. A rise in recorded violence can mean more violence, but it can also mean that the police record more of what is reported, that more victims report crimes, or that a definition has changed. For this reason the Scottish Crime and Justice Survey and the Crime Survey for England and Wales ask a sample of the public about crimes they have experienced, whether or not they were reported. Comparing the two sources shows how much crime goes unrecorded, and why a single source can mislead.

Evaluating an official statistic

A researcher should ask five questions of any official figure. What was counted, and how was the category defined? Who collected it, and for what purpose? When was it collected, and has the definition changed since? What is left out? How complete is the coverage? A figure that rests on a changed definition should not be compared with an older figure without a note of the change.

Official figures also need to be read in context. Unemployment figures in the United Kingdom are based on the International Labour Organization definition, which counts people as unemployed if they are without work, available for work and have looked for work in the previous four weeks, so a person who has stopped looking for work is not counted. A researcher who wants to know how many people are without paid work, rather than how many are officially unemployed, needs to look at economic inactivity figures as well.

Official reports and documents

Governments and public bodies also publish reports that are not statistical. A committee report from the Scottish Parliament, an inquiry into a prison death, a review of child protection and a policy paper from a department each give evidence and a point of view. These sources are valuable because they are written by people with access to information, but they are written to make a case. A report commissioned by a government and published by it is likely to present the government's policy in a favourable light, though it may also contain evidence that is hard to dispute. Reading the terms of reference, the list of who gave evidence and the recommendations tells a researcher what the report was for.

Private and personal documents, such as letters, diaries, minutes of meetings and emails, are a second type of record. They can show what someone thought at the time, which a later interview cannot always show, but they are selective. A letter is written for a particular reader, and a diary may have been kept with publication in mind. The researcher should ask who wrote the document, why it was kept, and who had access to it.

Using official statistics in a study

A study of inequality in Scotland might use the Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation, which ranks small areas on income, employment, health, education, crime, housing and access to services. Used with care, it shows which neighbourhoods have the most disadvantage, and it can be compared with the census to see whether the people living there match the picture. It is a strong source for the places it covers, but it measures deprivation in areas rather than in individuals, so it cannot by itself show that a particular family is poor.

The best use of official statistics is to combine them with other sources. Figures show the scale and the pattern, a survey shows what people believe and how they respond, and a document shows the reasons given by those who made the decisions. Each source has a gap that another can fill, and a student who names those gaps is evaluating the research rather than describing it.

さらに36件あります。上のリストから開けます。

レビュー

文章でのレビューはまだありません。このノートを自分のノートに追加して、最初のレビューを投稿できます。