コンテンツへ移動

Edexcel A level Religious Studies

A-Level · EdexcelReligious Studies8個のフォルダーに19件のノート、71 KB

Edexcel A-Level Religious Studiesの試験勉強用ノート19件。cookieが作成。コースのトピックに沿った8個のセクションに分かれています。

Notes in folders for Philosophy of Religion, Religion and Ethics, New Testament Studies and the religion options Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Hinduism and Buddhism. Sikhism is not covered. Delete the religion folders you do not study.

内容

最初のノート

Philosophy of Religion / Arguments from design and cause

The design argument

The design argument is an a posteriori argument: its premises come from experience of the world, and its reasoning is inductive, so its conclusion is probable rather than proved. It claims that the order and purpose found in nature are best explained by an intelligent designer, God.

William Paley gave the best-known form. Someone who finds a watch on a heath and examines its parts sees that they are arranged to tell the time, and infers a watchmaker. Paley argued that living things, such as the eye, show the same kind of arrangement of parts to a purpose, only more intricately, so they too must have a designer. He distinguished design as purpose, where parts serve an end, from design as regularity, where nature follows patterns such as the orbits of the planets.

Richard Swinburne developed the regularity form. He separated the regularity of succession, meaning laws of nature that govern how events follow each other, from the regularity of co-presence, meaning the ordered arrangement of things that exist together. He argued that a universe with such order is more probable if God exists than if it does not, and that the combined weight of many kinds of evidence, the cumulative effect, strengthens the case. The anthropic principle supports this: the constants of physics appear fine-tuned so that life can exist.

Hume's criticisms

David Hume criticised the argument in the Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion. Cleanthes presents the argument and the sceptic Philo attacks it. Philo makes these points:

  • An analogy between a universe and a machine is weak, because a universe is unique and we have no other universes to compare with it, whereas we can compare machines.
  • If the world is like a machine, the designer need not be one God, since many people build a ship, and the designer need not be perfect, since the world contains flaws.
  • Order might arise from the nature of matter itself, as a vegetable grows without a designer.

The strongest modern challenge comes from Darwinian evolution. Natural selection explains how complex adapted organisms can arise without foresight, so the apparent purpose in organisms has a natural explanation. Richard Dawkins uses the image of a blind watchmaker. Some believers respond that evolution is the means God used, and deists hold that God designed the laws and then left the universe to run.

The cosmological argument

The cosmological argument is also a posteriori and inductive. It starts from the existence of the universe, or from facts about it such as motion and causation, and argues to a first cause or necessary being.

Thomas Aquinas gave three cosmological ways. From motion, everything that moves is moved by something else, a chain that cannot go back for ever, so there is an unmoved mover. From causation, there must be a first uncaused cause. From contingency, things that exist might not have existed, and if everything were contingent there would once have been nothing, from which nothing could have come, so something necessary exists, which Aquinas calls God.

Two concepts matter here. A contingent thing depends on something else for its existence and could have failed to exist. A necessary being exists by its own nature. The principle of sufficient reason states that everything has a full explanation, which supports the search for a being whose existence explains itself.

The Kalam argument, from medieval Islamic thought and defended by William Lane Craig, runs: whatever begins to exist has a cause, the universe began to exist, so the universe has a cause. It aims to show that an actual infinite regress of past causes is impossible.

Criticisms

Hume argued that we have no experience of universes being caused, and that we cannot move from every event having a cause to the whole series having one. Bertrand Russell called this the fallacy of composition: every human has a mother, but the human race does not have a mother. Immanuel Kant argued that cause and effect are categories that apply within experience, so they cannot be used to reach a being outside it.

In their 1948 radio debate Russell said the universe is a brute fact, simply there, and that talk of a necessary being makes no sense because necessity belongs to statements, not things. Frederick Copleston replied that the contingent universe needs an explanation outside itself. The argument offers probability and not proof, and a believer must still show that the first cause is the God of religion and not an impersonal force.

さらに18件あります。上のリストから開けます。

レビュー

文章でのレビューはまだありません。このノートを自分のノートに追加して、最初のレビューを投稿できます。