OCR A level Psychology
20 notas de revisão de OCR A-Level Psychology, criadas por cookie, em 9 seções que seguem os tópicos do curso.
Notes for OCR A Level Psychology (H567), in folders for the three components: research methods, the psychological themes through core studies, and applied psychology. Each applied option has its own folder, so students can delete the two they do not take.
O que contém
A primeira anotação
Research methods / Experiments
Laboratory, field and quasi experiments
An experiment tests whether changing one variable causes a change in another. The researcher changes the independent variable on purpose, measures the dependent variable, and keeps everything else the same, so that any difference in the results can be put down to the change. Experiments come in three main forms. They differ mainly in how much control the researcher has over the setting and over the independent variable.
A laboratory experiment takes place in a controlled setting. Because the researcher controls the room, the timing, the instructions and the equipment, extraneous variables are kept to a minimum, so cause and effect can be shown with some confidence. The cost is realism. People who know they are in a laboratory, with a researcher watching, may behave differently from how they would at home or at work, so the findings can have low ecological validity.
A field experiment keeps the researcher's control over the independent variable but moves the study into a natural setting, such as a shopping centre, a school corridor or a railway platform. Participants are usually unaware that they are in a study, so their behaviour is more natural. The trade-off is that the researcher controls less. Weather, other people and chance events can all affect the dependent variable, and it is harder to be sure that the independent variable is the only thing that changed.
A quasi experiment is the form in which the independent variable is not set by the researcher at all. It is a difference that already exists between people, such as gender, age, or whether someone has a particular condition or experience. Researchers use quasi experiments when a variable cannot be manipulated ethically or practically. The groups cannot be randomly allocated, though, so they may differ in other ways as well. A quasi experiment can show a difference between groups, but it is weaker on cause and effect.
Choosing between them
Two questions help to keep the three apart. How much control does the researcher have over the setting, and how much control over the independent variable? A laboratory experiment has high control over both. A field experiment has high control over the variable but low control over the setting. A quasi experiment has low control over the variable, because the difference is naturally occurring.
Writing about strengths and weaknesses
Evaluation works best when each point is tied to the design. High control in a laboratory is a strength only when it is linked to a result: changes in the dependent variable can then be attributed to the independent variable. An artificial setting is a weakness only when it is linked to behaviour, such as people acting differently from how they would in everyday life. A point counts when it names the variable that is controlled, or the behaviour that might change.
Worked example
Suppose a researcher wants to know whether background noise affects reading speed. In a laboratory, the researcher can play a set level of noise to one group and silence to another, use the same passage for everyone, and time each reader with the same stopwatch. Any difference in reading speed is then easy to attribute to the noise.
In a library, the researcher could instead record reading times for people who happen to sit near a loud photocopier, and compare them with people sitting in a quiet corner. The noise is a naturally occurring difference, so this is a quasi experiment. The researcher cannot rule out that the two groups differ in other ways. The people near the photocopier might have chosen a busy floor, or might have been reading different material.
The first design has more control, and the second is closer to real life. Neither is better in every respect, and a good answer says which of the two matters more for the question being asked.
Key terms
A laboratory experiment is carried out in a controlled setting. A field experiment is carried out in a natural setting with the independent variable manipulated. A quasi experiment uses an independent variable that is a naturally occurring difference between groups.
E mais 19: abra qualquer um deles na lista acima.
Avaliações
Ainda não há avaliações escritas. Adicione estas notas às suas e você poderá ser a primeira pessoa a deixar uma avaliação.