콘텐츠로 건너뛰기

OCR A level Religious Studies

A-Level · OCRReligious Studies노트 24개, 폴더 3개, 83 KB

cookie가 만든 OCR A-Level Religious Studies 복습 노트 24개예요. 과정의 주제에 따라 3개 섹션으로 구성돼요.

Notes for OCR A level Religious Studies (H573), in three folders: Philosophy of religion, Religion and ethics, and Developments in Christian thought. Each note covers one topic, with the thinkers, arguments and criticisms. Other Developments options (Islam, Judaism, Buddhism, Hinduism) are not covered.

포함된 내용

첫 번째 노트

Philosophy of religion / Plato and Aristotle

Philosophy of religion borrows its vocabulary from two Greek thinkers, Plato and Aristotle. They disagree about where knowledge comes from, and later arguments about God inherit that disagreement.

Plato: reason and the Forms

Plato (c. 428-348 BC) was a rationalist: he trusted reason over the senses. The senses show a world that is always changing, so what they report is opinion at best. Real knowledge must be about something that does not change. Plato called these unchanging patterns the Forms. A beautiful painting, a beautiful face and a beautiful poem are all beautiful because each shares in the Form of Beauty, which is perfect and eternal. Physical things are copies of the Forms and so less real than them.

The Forms form a hierarchy. At the top is the Form of the Good, which gives the other Forms their value and makes them knowable. In the Republic Plato compares it to the sun: as the sun lets us see physical objects and makes them grow, the Form of the Good lets the mind grasp the other Forms.

The analogy of the cave

In Book VII of the Republic Plato asks the reader to picture prisoners chained in a cave since birth, facing a wall. Behind them a fire burns, and people carry objects along a walkway in front of it, so that shadows move across the wall. The prisoners take the shadows for reality and even compete at naming them.

One prisoner is freed and forced to turn round. The firelight hurts his eyes and the objects seem less clear than the shadows he knew. He is dragged up out of the cave into daylight, where he is at first blinded, and only gradually can he see shadows, then reflections, then the things themselves, and finally the sun.

Each part stands for something.

Part of the caveWhat it stands for
Shadows on the wallThe appearances known through the senses
The fireThe sun of the physical world, a weak light
The painful climb outThe difficult education of the philosopher
The world outsideThe world of the Forms, known by reason
The sunThe Form of the Good

The freed prisoner is under a duty to go back down and teach the others. When he does, his eyes cannot adjust to the dark, so he seems foolish, and the prisoners threaten to kill anyone who tries to lead them up. The point of the story is that most people mistake appearance for reality, and that philosophy is the slow, uncomfortable process of seeing what is truly good.

Aristotle: the senses and four causes

Aristotle (384-322 BC) was Plato's pupil and an empiricist. He put the forms of things inside the things themselves, so understanding reality begins with observing the world. He was also a teleologist: he believed that to understand a thing one must know its purpose or end (telos).

The four causes

Aristotle said that a full explanation of any thing gives four causes, set out in Physics II.3 and Metaphysics V.2.

CauseQuestion it answersA bronze statue
MaterialWhat is it made of?Bronze
FormalWhat shape or pattern makes it what it is?The shape of the figure
EfficientWhat brought it about?The sculptor
FinalWhat is it for?To honour a person

The final cause is the most important for religion, since it makes purpose part of the explanation of the world.

The Prime Mover

Aristotle saw that everything in motion is moved by something else, and that a series of movers cannot go back for ever. There must be a first mover that is itself unmoved: the Prime Mover. It is pure actuality, with no unrealised potential, so it cannot change. It is eternal and immaterial. It does not create the universe, which Aristotle believed was eternal, and it does not push anything. It moves things as the object of their desire, in the way something loved draws a person towards it. In this sense the Prime Mover is the final cause of the whole universe. Aristotle said it thinks only about itself, because only the best object of thought is worthy of a perfect mind.

Comparing the two thinkers

Plato and Aristotle share a belief that reality has an ordered, rational structure with something supreme at its top. They differ in method and in what the supreme thing is.

The Form of the Good is a Form, known by reason and separate from the physical world, and it makes things good and knowable. The Prime Mover is a being that causes motion by attraction and is reached by reasoning from observed change. Plato relies on reason alone (rationalism) and Aristotle on observation of the world (empiricism). Aristotle's criticism of the Forms was that they sit apart from things and so cannot explain how things change or come to exist.

Later theologians used both. Plato's belief in a higher, perfect reality shaped Christian ideas of heaven and the soul, and Aristotle's causes and Prime Mover underlie Aquinas' arguments for God.

그 밖에 23개 더 있어요. 위 목록에서 원하는 항목을 열어 보세요.

평가

아직 작성된 후기가 없어요. 이 노트를 내 노트에 추가하면 가장 먼저 후기를 남길 수 있어요.