Eduqas A level Law
20 catatan belajar untuk Eduqas A-Level Law, dibuat oleh cookie, dalam 5 bagian yang mengikuti topik kursus.
Notes for WJEC Eduqas A level Law (A150), in folders for the nature of law and the English legal system and for each area of substantive law, with one folder per area of law so a student keeps the areas they study and deletes the others. Follows the Eduqas specification for teaching from 2017, version 2 (2019).
Isi di dalamnya
Catatan pertama
Nature of law and the English legal system / Law and society, morality and justice
What law is for
Law is a set of rules that the state enforces, and it sits alongside other rules that people follow without any legal sanction, such as manners, religious duties and the customs of a club. What makes a rule legal is that a court or an official can enforce it, and that breaking it can bring a penalty or a remedy. Criminal law and civil law are the two main branches. Criminal law is brought by the state against a person accused of an offence, and the aim is punishment, deterrence and protection of the public. Civil law is brought by one person against another to resolve a dispute, and the usual aim is compensation or an order to put something right.
Law draws its sources from several places. Statute is written law made by Parliament. Common law is judge-made law developed through decisions of the courts. Custom is a long-standing practice, accepted as binding by a community, which the courts may recognise where it is ancient, reasonable and certain. Each source has its own method of creation and its own way of being changed, and the nature of law becomes clearer when these sources are compared.
The rule of law
The rule of law is the idea that the state and its officials must act under the law, and that no one is above it. A V Dicey set out three forms of the principle in the late nineteenth century. The first is the supremacy of regular law, meaning that a person is punished only for a clear breach of law and not for arbitrary reasons. The second is equality before the law, meaning that ordinary courts apply the same law to officials as to private citizens. The third is that the constitution is the result of the ordinary law of the land, so that rights come from judicial decisions and statutes rather than from a single written document.
Modern versions of the rule of law add that law should be clear, accessible and stable, and that the executive should not be able to create or change law without legal authority. Delegated legislation and the royal prerogative both test these ideas, because both allow government to make rules outside the normal parliamentary process. The courts therefore review them.
Human rights and balancing interests
Human rights are rights that every person holds because they are human. In English law they are protected by the Human Rights Act 1998, which gives effect in domestic courts to the rights in the European Convention on Human Rights. Many legal disputes involve the balancing of conflicting interests. A landlord wants to recover possession of a property, while a tenant wants to keep their home. A business wants to publish information, while another person wants their privacy protected. Courts resolve these clashes by identifying each interest and deciding which should prevail in the circumstances.
Public and private interests are often weighed in the same way. A public interest, such as public safety or the prevention of crime, can justify limiting an individual's freedom. The law accepts that individual rights are sometimes subordinated to community interests, but it requires that the limit be justified and proportionate.
Law and morality
The relationship between law and morality is one of the oldest debates in legal theory. Morals are standards of right and wrong held by society. Law is a set of rules enforced by the state. The two overlap, since many crimes such as theft and violence are also immoral, but they are not the same. An action can be immoral without being illegal, and some laws do not match any widely held moral view.
The debate between H L A Hart and Lord Devlin in the 1960s is the classic statement of the question. The Wolfenden Report of 1957 had recommended that homosexual acts between consenting adults in private should no longer be criminal, and the question was whether the state should enforce a shared public morality. Devlin argued that society has a right to protect its moral framework, and that a society is held together by shared values. Hart replied that the state should punish conduct because it harms others, and not because it offends the moral views of the majority. Hart's position draws on the harm principle of John Stuart Mill. In a pluralist society, where people hold different moral, religious and political views, Hart's approach limits the state to preventing harm.
Law and justice
Justice is a central concept in law, but its meaning is contested. Distributive justice concerns the fair allocation of benefits and burdens among members of society. Corrective justice concerns putting right a wrong done by one person to another, usually through compensation. John Rawls, in A Theory of Justice (1971), argued that the principles of justice should be chosen behind a veil of ignorance, where no one knows their place in society, so that the principles are fair to everyone.
Substantive rules, legal institutions and legal processes can each be tested against whether they achieve justice or create barriers to it. A substantive rule can be a barrier where a strict time limit prevents a claimant with a genuine case from succeeding. An institution can be a barrier where court fees and the cost of representation put a claim beyond reach. A process can be a barrier where its complexity and delay make it hard for an unrepresented person to take part. A useful test is to identify a specific feature of the law, explain how it limits access, and ask whether the limit is justified.
Dan 19 lainnya: buka yang kamu mau dari daftar di atas.
Ulasan
Belum ada ulasan tertulis. Tambahkan catatan ini ke catatanmu dan jadilah yang pertama memberi ulasan.