SQA Higher Modern Studies
33 apuntes de estudio, creados por cookie, en 4 secciones que siguen los temas del curso.
Notes for SQA Higher Modern Studies (C849 76), in folders for the three areas of study and the source skills, with one folder per social issue option and per world power or world issue. Follows the course specification, version 4.0 (September 2024). Delete any folder your class does not study once the notes are yours.
Qué contiene
La primera nota
Democracy in Scotland and the United Kingdom / The UK constitution and institutions
What the constitution is
A constitution sets out who holds power, how they get it, and what limits they must observe. Most countries write theirs into one document. The United Kingdom does not. Its constitution is unwritten in that sense, but it is not unregulated. It is made up of four kinds of source, and each one can change in a different way.
Statute is law passed by Parliament, such as the Human Rights Act 1998 or the Scotland Act 1998. Common law is built up by judges in their decisions, which later courts follow. Conventions are rules of behaviour that everyone in politics follows without any court enforcing them, such as the convention that the monarch gives royal assent to bills. Treaties, such as the agreements that took the UK into and out of the European Union, bind the state in international law and shape domestic law too.
Because the constitution is spread across these sources, it can be changed by an ordinary Act of Parliament. Nothing needs a special majority or a referendum, unless Parliament chooses to require one, as it did for Scottish independence in 2014 under an agreed process.
Parliamentary sovereignty
The central principle is parliamentary sovereignty. Parliament can make or unmake any law, and no other body can set aside its legislation. A.V. Dicey set out this principle in Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution in 1885, and it still shapes how the courts behave.
The principle has limits in practice. Courts cannot strike down an Act of Parliament, but they can interpret it, and since the Human Rights Act 1998 took effect in 2000 they can declare that legislation is incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights, a step that leaves the law in force. Membership of the EU, which lasted from 1973 until 31 January 2020, meant that EU law took precedence over UK statute in areas it covered. Devolution adds a further limit: the Scottish Parliament can legislate only on devolved matters, and Westminster has not removed its own power to legislate for Scotland.
The legislature
Parliament has two chambers. The House of Commons has 650 members, each elected from a single constituency at a general election, and it is the chamber that controls the government. The House of Lords is the second chamber. Most of its members are life peers appointed on the advice of the political parties and an independent commission, along with bishops and a small number of judges. The Parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949 limit the Lords' power to delay bills: it can delay a bill passed by the Commons for a limited time, and the Commons can force it through in the end.
A bill passes through both Houses in stages. It has a first and second reading, committee stage, report stage and third reading in each House, and then receives royal assent. Most bills start in the Commons, and the government controls most of the time for debate.
The executive
The executive is the government. The Prime Minister leads it and chooses the Cabinet from among the members of the two Houses. The government can govern because it commands a majority in the Commons, and a government that loses a confidence vote is expected to resign or call an election. The Prime Minister is head of government, while the monarch is head of state. The monarch's powers are exercised on ministerial advice, so the royal prerogative, the old body of powers the Crown holds, is used by ministers in practice.
The executive and legislature are linked rather than separated. Most ministers sit in Parliament, which is the reverse of the separation of powers used in the United States, and this closeness is one reason critics argue that the executive often dominates the legislature.
The judiciary
The judges sit in the courts and, since the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 took effect in October 2009, the Supreme Court is the highest court for civil cases across the UK and for criminal cases in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. In Scotland the High Court of Justiciary is the final court for criminal cases, so the Supreme Court is not the last word on every criminal matter there. The Supreme Court decides whether devolved bodies have acted within their powers. In 2022 it ruled that the Scottish Parliament could not hold a second independence referendum without the consent of the UK Parliament, a decision that shows the courts settling a constitutional question the political system could not resolve on its own.
Devolution and the territorial constitution
The UK is a union of four nations, and power is divided in unequal ways. The Scottish Parliament, the Senedd and the Northern Ireland Assembly each have legislative powers that differ in scope. Scotland's arrangement is the widest. Its Parliament can legislate on any matter not reserved to Westminster, such as health, education and justice, while defence, the currency and most of the tax system stay reserved.
A convention, now set out in the Scotland Act 2016, says that Westminster will not normally legislate on a devolved matter without the agreement of the devolved legislature. This is called the Sewel convention after Lord Sewel, who proposed it in 1998.
A worked example of the balance of power
Suppose a government holds 350 of the 650 seats in the Commons. A majority needs 326, so the government has 24 seats to spare. It can pass a bill that the Lords dislikes, because the Parliament Acts allow the Commons to override a refusal to pass a bill. The Lords can still delay the bill, but the delay is limited to the period set in the Acts. In this case the Lords has power to revise and to delay, but not to block. A constitution that gives the executive a reliable majority, and that leaves the courts unable to overturn statute, gives the government a great deal of room, which is why the UK's arrangements are often described as a system where the executive is strong.
Why this matters
Students of the UK constitution are usually asked to judge whether the balance between the executive, the legislature and the courts works well. The better answers say which of the constitution's features help and which do harm, and they use real events to show it: the Brexit votes, the 2014 Scottish referendum, the Supreme Court's rulings on Parliament's role, and the way the government's majority has been used to pass controversial bills.
Y 32 más: abre cualquiera desde la lista de arriba.
Reseñas
Todavía no hay reseñas escritas. Añade estas notas a las tuyas y podrás ser la primera persona en dejar una.